Clinical Pathways Can Lead to Cost Savings, Better Care

Marcus Neubauer, MD
Published: Thursday, Dec 18, 2014
Dr. Marcus Neubauer

Marcus Neubauer, MD

Think back to what healthcare was like in the early 1980s. Thirty years ago, electronic health records and oral chemotherapy were hardly blips on the radar, and vertical integration was in its infancy. Even though the healthcare environment was very different, many of the challenges we face today are the same. Rising costs, an aging population, and higher rates of chronic disease were issues back then for private and government payers, providers and patients, just as they are now. Several initiatives that have a dramatic impact on healthcare today were born during that time–managed care, transitioning away from inpatient care toward outpatient care, and the introduction of clinical pathways.

Originally, pathways focused on standardizing care as a way of managing the quality of care provided. The goal was to reduce unnecessary variability in clinical practice and improve outcomes. Evidence-based guidelines were developed and adopted throughout healthcare from general practice to specialties—including oncology. Over the years, the role of pathways has evolved and expanded significantly. Today, they are not only effective tools for improving the quality of care, but also for driving value in healthcare.

Proof of Pathways as a Driver of Value

The idea of driving value with pathways has gained the attention of payers, providers, and many thought leaders in cancer care. Treatment of cancer, in particular, has been identified as one of the fastest-rising cost centers in healthcare and has come under scrutiny for high drug costs, high rates of hospitalizations, and potentially unnecessary and expensive end-of-life care. Several studies from McKesson Specialty Health and The US Oncology Network reported over the last decade support for the use of evidence- based guidelines, specifically Level I Pathways, as an effective method of lowering cost while still demonstrating outcomes similar to those in the published literature. Level I Pathways, which were developed nearly 10 years ago by The US Oncology Network, are now refined into Value Pathways powered by the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN)—the result of the recent collaboration between the NCCN, McKesson Specialty Health, and The US Oncology Network.

A study conducted by The US Oncology Network and Milliman compared patients with colon cancer whose care followed physiciandeveloped Level I Pathways (also known as “on-pathway”) with other patients (“off-pathway”). The study found mean per patient cost differences of more than 30 percent (favoring the on-pathway group).1

Another study looked at patients with non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) treated in the community outpatient setting. Cost of care over a 12-month period and overall survival were compared between patients treated on-pathway versus off-pathway, and the study found overall outpatient costs to be 35 percent lower for on-pathway versus off-pathway choices (average 12-month cost, $18,042 vs $27,737, respectively) with no difference in overall survival observed.2 Results of both of these studies suggest that treating patients according to clinical pathways is a cost-effective strategy for delivering care, and highlights opportunities for oncologists to help rein in cancer care costs.

How Pathways Help Reduce Costs

Pathways help reduce costs by standardizing care. One of the biggest cost drivers in healthcare is high variability in care. This is especially true in the treatment of cancer, given the high and variable costs of oncology drugs. Following pathways leads oncologists down a path that ultimately results in a treatment option that has been proved the most clinically effective and cost-effective option. Pathways were developed with clinical efficacy, toxicity, and cost taken into consideration. In other words, when developing a pathway to treat a specific type of cancer, if 2 drugs offer the same efficacy and toxicity, the lower-cost drug, often a generic drug, is selected as the pathway treatment option. This also improves the predictability of cost for payers and patients.


View Conference Coverage
Online CME Activities
TitleExpiration DateCME Credits
Community Practice Connections™: 18th Annual International Lung Cancer Congress®Oct 31, 20181.5
Provider and Caregiver Connection™: Addressing Patient Concerns While Managing Chemotherapy Induced Nausea and VomitingOct 31, 20182.0
Publication Bottom Border
Border Publication
x